4

The GIS Meta Q&A on Keep or delete [qgis-3] version tag? has resulted in:

  • all the QGIS 3.x tags being made synonyms of the tag; and
  • all the QGIS 2.x tags being made synonyms of the tag
  • the two QGIS 1.x tags being made synonyms of the tag

Should we now do the same for the version tags being used with ArcGIS Desktop and ArcGIS Server?

4

I do not agree. There are significant changes to ArcGIS in v10 later versions, including but not limited to:

  • Support for ASPRS LAS v1.4.
  • Support for GDA2020.
  • Classify LAS building and Tile LAS tools.

Read more about What's new in 10.5. The sub-releases only contain minor changes and bugfixes but each minor release contains significant changes. If a user is limited only to ArcGIS 10 as a tag there is a potential for confusion if they are using an earlier release and are receiving answers in a later release, this would mean for every question tagged ArcGIS 10 the first comment would always be "which minor version of ArcGIS 10 do you have installed?".

3

Yes.

I think we should make:

  • all the ArcGIS 10.x tags become synonyms of an tag; and
  • all the ArcGIS 9.x tags become synonyms of an tag

The reasons that I think we should do this are:

  • to simplify ArcGIS version tagging
  • the case for separate dot release tags was strong in the ArcGIS 9.1, 9.2, 9.3, 10.0 and 10.1 era but with each subsequent dot release changes between them have become more and more minor

I still encourage askers of ArcGIS questions to always mention the precise version(s) they are asking about within the body of those questions.

  • 1
    10.0 and 10.1 were similar releases, however I believe 10.2 or 10.3 was a fairly major update, and there is significant difference between 10.1 and 10.3. I'm not sure quite how we could accommodate that though, or if we even should. But overall I agree that we should try to synonymize where we can – Midavalo Feb 14 at 18:51
  • @Midavalo If you're talking "Server": Server underwent massive changes between <=10.0 and >=10.1. Desktop has had a relatively even increase in enhancements over each .dot release (noting the biggest changes were 9.3 to 10.0, a full release) – KHibma Feb 14 at 20:37
  • @Midavalo the big differences I saw between 10.0 and 10.1 was in ArcPy when arcpy.da, Python Toolboxes and Python AddIns were added. – PolyGeo Feb 14 at 21:24
  • 2
    If there's no way to distinguish between 10.1 and 10.6 via tags, then the arcgis-10 tag will be worthless. Posters keep tagging 10.5 questions as 10.0, so I'd be fine with retiring 10.0/10.1 from service, but you might as well synonymize arcgis-10 with arcgis for all the use it would be. – Vince Feb 15 at 19:09
  • @Vince I kind of agree. I thought about proposing arcgis-10.0, arcgis-10.1 and arcgis-10.2+. I've gone for the simplest version tagging possible. I'm aware that it only distinguishes between ArcGIS 9.x (few questions) and 10.x. – PolyGeo Feb 17 at 9:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .