When looking for a link to give to someone new to the site about what kind of answers we look for I noticed the FAQ talks a lot about how to ask good questions but not about good answers.

Kind of a strange omission since it's actually good answers that folks are after. Even stranger that it took me 18 months to notice!

I wonder if it would be useful to have a series of before and after examples to show. For example:

Q: Where can i find Yak migration data?

Poor A: Yakyaka.com has a ton of great data, have you tried there?

Better A: Yakyaka.com has an archive going back to 1764, though the period from 1812-1855 is a bit sketchy. For quick overview of the holdings see the [online map viewer] and the raw .csv and shapefiles are on their [ftp site]. Note the data is free but commercial use requires permission (usually easily granted).

  • 4
    Sounds good to me. How do we go about updating the FAQ? – Kirk Kuykendall Feb 14 '12 at 4:05
  • Along those lines, the FAQ examples and screenshots are from the Bicycles.se site, can these also be tailored to GIS.se? – Chad Cooper Feb 14 '12 at 19:51
  • Mods can edit only the first section of the FAQ, which is the text spanning (but not including) "What kind of questions can I ask here?" and "Please look around to see if your question has been asked before...". Changing anything else might require a system-wide modification! I have added the feature-request tag to see whether we can get someone from SE to weigh in. – whuber Feb 14 '12 at 21:47
  • 1
    @ChadCooper what examples and screenshots are you referring to? Thanks for mentioning Bicycles.se, I hadn't run into it yet. They have an interesting take on how to build a terminology page which might be worth emulating. – matt wilkie Feb 15 '12 at 18:06
  • @mattwilkie - look at the How to ask questions here section for a bicyles screenshot. – Chad Cooper Feb 16 '12 at 14:13
  • The FAQ link has for many years redirected to the Tour so, while the intent of this question is important, I think its text needs to be heavily revised. – PolyGeo Jul 18 at 22:32

The new help center page now addresses answering.

How do I write a good answer? section is a start link one can provide for new users.

Additionally, we might consider building a GIS Meta thread with specific guidelines to improve answering on GIS SE.

How to answer on GIS SE?

We already started this with questions:

What makes a good question?

As these kind of threads become mature, they can evolve to a FAQ status.
For example, in Cross Validated Meta, there are specific how to ask and how to answer threads.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .