38

Yes, GIS should participate in Winter Bash 2014.


29

Yes I think geospatial is for all intents and purposes a synonym of GIS and thus any case for blacklisting the gis tag should apply equally to geospatial. gis was blacklisted long ago so I think blacklisting of geospatial is long overdue.


28

Homer Simpson says "Yes (participate)" better than I can.


24

Seven ways to help revive/refresh a question (including closed questions), and its answers are by: using the share button beneath the question to advertise it to your networks (no rep needed) suggesting an edit to improve it that then gets approved i.e. provide additional details or clarify existing details (no rep needed) raising the need for more editors/...


24

I believe that QGIS 3.0 and QGIS 3.2 are essentially the same series. QGIS 3.4 comes out 26/10/2018 and also belongs in the same series. Additionally, a lot of plugins and features are being ported to the new versions. I believe our energy would be best used to try and optimise the latest release. I believe only 2 tags are needed going forwards: qgis-2 and ...


22

Vote Early, Vote Often Upvoting answers, when warranted, quickly moves questions off the Unanswered list if they have a net 0 vote. Downvoting answers, when warranted, helps to push low quality questions towards the Roomba which can delete them from the site (and thus off the Unanswered list), if the community voting indicates that they have little value. ...


19

Vote for this Answer if you think the homework tag should be burninated.


16

I've watched this post for the past couple days...spending way more time than anyone should reading edit history and comments. That nonsense in itself is why I quit on GIS.SE for a few months. But me going on about that is not an answer to the question. That point in itself is a problem - this "question" is now different than the original question. Now that ...


15

Yes we definitely should have hats!


14

I support Burninating this tag, because it is pretty much a Meta Tag. It does not give any additional information about the question, and most of the time, the issue might not even be a Bug.


14

I think Here Maps is more on-topic here at GIS SE than it would be at Stack Overflow. We have currently not had all that many questions tagged here-maps and would welcome more. As on any site, be sure to: take our 2-minute Tour; review the first (on topic) page of the help review a few recent Q&As to get a feel for what potential answerers are looking ...


14

...should the email be removed? Yes, personal information goes in the user profile page. Posts must be kept as clean as possible, i.e, without user signatures, salutations, and other kinds of unrelated messages with the Q/A content.


13

Having looked at the questions tagged latitude & longitude, I whole heartedly agree that the current usage of these tags on most of these questions (there are 89 question currently tagged with both) is unhelpful, and the tags should be removed from these questions. In most questions, these tags could be replaced by the new lat-long tag. However, I ...


13

Last year's poll was so clearly in favour of Hats (see Should GIS participate in the 2014 “Winter Bash”?) that I proposed to the other mods that we simply accept the default option which is that we get Hats. Just for a bit more transparency, the relevant contents of the email to moderators about this year's hats were: As moderators in our network, you ...


12

See the following Meta Stack Exchange posts: What is a disputed flag? What is the difference between disputed and declined flags? From the last post: Disputed flag: When you flag an answer as NAA or VLQ and the post doesn't result in deletion but someone recommended deletion, the flag is disputed. Spam and offensive flags on post that are rolled back ...


12

I think this tag is redundant. Any question relating to code should have the language tag associated with it. I vote to burninate.


12

I was not one of the three users (two moderators) who cast or processed flags on your answer. However, as a moderator I can confirm that these actions happened, as you can see below: Ordinary user cast a spam flag Moderator 1 declined the spam flag Moderator 2 cast a spam flag (which deleted your answer, and presumably led to the 100 point deduction) I ...


11

Firstly, congratulations! It was quite a job organizing the 'arcgis' tag. I believe we should definitely blacklist it. Users will use the correct tag from now on (when typing 'arcgis', they will see the alternative tags and be able to make the correct choice, as mentioned by Sideshow Bob). There will be less tag-editings bumping posts to the active page, ...


11

How many flags do I have? When you start out, you are allotted 10 flags per day. This number may increase to up to 100 flags per day: You get one bonus flag per 2000 reputation. You are awarded additional bonus flags when you flag correctly - one bonus flag for every ten net helpful flags (helpful flags minus declined flags). https://gis.stackexchange....


10

Thanks Curlew! I think now is exactly the right time to talk about this. From my point of view, I think qgis-processing would be a better choice than processing-toolbox since the toolbox is only one feature of the whole processing (mhm, "framework"?). I'd suggest to start correcting tags for all new questions and the old ones which already concern QGIS 2.0 ...


10

Something I think we need to be cautious about is opening the door to "absolutely any question related to Surveying, etc". Perhaps we can model our answer on the Cross Validated Tour which I have modified here to try and suit our purposes and emphasize that our "core business" is GIS but that we are happy to see questions from other spatial disciplines. ...


10

The explanation is over in the sidebar. Can we raise the bar for reputation for late answers to bypass the review queue? It started at almost 900 this morning so we are getting through them quite quickly.


10

The yellow highlighted questions are those that contain one of your favorite tags. You can edit the tags on your GIS SE home page by selecting the "edit" hyperlink. Note that in addition to adding favorite tags, you can add ignore tags, which will grey out questions.


10

I would like to drop the last sentence: Questions that are too basic (meaning the answer is indexed in any number of general internet reference sources designed specifically to find that type of information) will be closed. I like to consider GIS SE as the ultimate repository for questions all along the spectrum from basic to advanced. Why would we ...


10

It is possible, but difficult, to propose new badges, and I think that they can only be proposed network-wide rather than site-specific. The process is described at What makes a good badge? When and why should I suggest a new badge?


10

Comments do not support the insertion of images. To do that you need to be editing your question (via Ask Question or using the edit button beneath an existing question). Its the same as for an answer so I'll screenshot this and circle the picture button in red. To better understand the purpose of comments I recommend reviewing How do comments work? and to ...


10

I agree, and propose this wording that incorporates suggestions from @whuber: Questions that relate to the business of vendors and product teams, such as licensing, pricing, release dates, submission of bug reports and enhancement requests, etc, are off-topic here and should be directed instead to the official software support teams. I have not ...


9

It has been removed in the latest build, as per this discussion on meta.stackoverflow.


9

Post another question about the new problem, referencing the old one to avoid duplication of effort and narrowing the problem space down. So in the general good question style: "I've had problems with A and /this/ fixed it, but now I have an additional constraint B and need help with adapting the model. I've tried C and D, but ...".


9

I would say to just leave it, as (and this is just one reason) it could be used as a statistic to help find "canonical" questions. In other words, if a question has been referenced many times by duplicated questions, it might be considered canonical. There might be ways to query this information out of the Stack Exchange Data Explorer, e.g. Most Commonly ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible